Make a difference—get involved Connect with us Follow us on Twitter Become a Fan on Facebook

Money Madness or Money Miracle? You Decide.

Would you dump the stocks in your retirement portfolio in exchange for greatly reduced risk?

The traditional investment advice is to buy stocks and hold them for the long run.   The problem is that there have been many long periods of time when the stock market remained essentially flat or even negative.  Most recently, stocks lost about -.95% a year over the ten year period ending in 2009.  That doesn’t even include losses from commissions, trading costs, investment management fees, taxes, and performance chasing.

In fact, Boston University finance professor Zvi Bodie argues that stocks are actually riskier in the long run.  His approach is to minimize risk by investing all his assets in federal government guaranteed inflation-protected bonds TIPS (treasury inflation protected securities).  These bonds are guaranteed at maturity and pay a fixed interest rate based on a principal value that is adjusted for inflation.  TIPS still have the risk of falling values if interest rates increase or having to reinvest your principal at lower rates when they come due but both of these risks can be mitigated by buying them in a mutual fund or in a laddered portfolio with different maturities.  Perhaps the biggest problem with this strategy is the paltry returns you’ll get in this current low interest rate environment.  That means you’ll have to save that much more to produce enough income in retirement.  Is it worth the peace of mind?  Is this money madness or a money miracle?

Voice your opinions in the comments.

See previous articles in Money Madness or Money Miracle

Today's Featured Articles

This Week in Financial Literacy (March 5, 2010)

  • Time to get back to basics.  Here’s a good article that describes How To Design Your Own Financial Literacy Curriculum. As the author of the article states, this is one topic that student’s won’t feel compelled to ask, “when are we ever going to need to use this?”
  • The United Way of San Antonio and Bexar County will use a FINRA grant it is receiving to implement a neighbor-to-neighbor financial education program and public education campaign for people living in low-income neighborhoods.  According to the article in the San Antonio Business Journal, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is donating roughly $1.5 million to 12 community groups nationwide as part of its new program, Financial Education in Your Community, which is administered jointly with United Way Worldwide.
  • Watch a short video from FoxProvidence.com about the National Financial Capability Challenge.
  • More fun: The University at Buffalo School of Management and M&T Bank will host more than 80 students from 16 public, private and charter schools in the third annual “MoneySKILL® Mania,” a financial literacy competition for high school juniors and seniors. The event will run from 9-11 a.m. on March 9 in UB’s Center for the Arts Screening Room on the North Campus.
  • Finally, WalletPOP.com has a quick quiz to test your financial literacy knowledge.  How did you score?

Financial Literacy: The Foundation for Building Wealth

flickr / Christopher Saccar

flickr / Christopher Saccaro

I ran across an article last week (Young Adults Need To Seek Wealth Literacy, Not Financial Literacy) which suggested that there is a problem with current financial literacy programs and that we ought to be teaching young people about building wealth instead. The author argues, “there is a loss of translation in somewhere between the sound principles of financial literacy and its usefulness in creating wealth… none of these traditional business or financial literacy courses really teach any student how to create wealth.”

On a certain level, I agree with the assertion that basic financial literacy doesn’t always offer specific solutions to wealth generation, but I certainly don’t think basic, sound, financial literacy doesn’t have a place in a person’s overall financial education. In fact, I would argue the opposite: that these “basics” such as budgeting, saving and credit management are the foundation of wealth creation. Having lots of money is no guarantee of future financial security. There are plenty of once wealthy people who have since become destitute which proves this.

Is there a disconnect between basic financial literacy principles and  the creation of wealth?  Leave a comment and let us know what you think.

Two examples of why financial literacy may be even more important now

These two articles about the aftermath of the recently enacted credit card rules demonstrate the shortcomings and unintended consequences of financial regulation and the need for financial literacy.

The first article shows how credit card companies are instituting new fees to replace the ones that are now illegal and finding clever ways to trick borrowers into paying higher interest rates.

The second one discusses how risky borrowers are losing access to credit cards and turning to even worse pay day lenders instead.  There really is no substitute for educated consumers.

This week in financial literacy (February 13, 2009)

  • The Anderson Library at the University of Wisconsin Whitewater posted a couple links to sites where you can test your own financial literacy.  They also listed a number of resources that can be found in their library (and maybe yours) to improve your own financial knowledge.
  • There will be a free financial education seminar sponsored by Carver Federal Savings Bank, Fidelity Investments & SBLI USA with guest Congressman Charles B. Rangel (D) at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture on Saturday, February 20, 2010.  This seminar, Your Money and You, is free and will be open to the public to attend.  More details are in the press release.
  • The comptroller of the state of Maryland urges all Maryland voters to support legislation introduced in the General Assembly that would require Maryland high school students to complete a stand-alone course in financial literacy to graduate from high school.
  • A series of talks about various personal finance topics is set to launch at the Tulsa City-County Hardesty Regional Library.  The first session on March 11th will be about “Debt Management and Consolidation.”

This week in financial literacy (February 6, 2009)

  • Financial literacy programs are starting up everywhere.  Keep up the good work!  Eastern Kentucky University announced this week the establishment of a financial literacy training program designed specifically to serve low- and moderate-income communities in eastern Kentucky. According to their press release:

    The University will prepare students and community leaders to become certified financial literacy instructors, and the instructors, in turn, will help community members to make informed financial decisions and take control of their financial future.

  • This arrived in my inbox this week.  The Social Security Adminitration (SSA) has established a new Financial Literacy Research Consortium made up of various research centers at universities and the RAND Corporation.

    Supported through five-year cooperative agreements, the centers will develop innovative, research-based communications and programs to help Americans plan and save for a secure retirement.

  • This is interesting, a series of children’s books has come out called The Financial Fairy Tales. These books are designed to, “introduce principles of saving, borrowing and investment to your children at an early age and help them to make sound financial decisions later in life. “The first book called, “Dreams Can Come True”

    …tells the story of Tom, the woodcutter’s son, with big dreams. Under the mentorship of his wealthy uncle, can he overcome his humble beginnings and reach the life of his dreams? Or is success snatched away at the last minute?